Wednesday, June 13, 2012


Stories 2 - Death Road and Beyond


Death Road and Beyond

                                        'Death road'  La Paz  to Coroico  in Bolivia

Recollections of the Unexpected, the Shocking and the Beautiful on a Trip down the Andes and through the Bolivian Rain Forest

By Kenneth Margo

‘Do not wander without a purpose, but in your impulses render what is just, and in all your imagination preserve what it is you apprehend’. (Meditations – Marcus Aurelius Bk 1V no 22)
‘Humility is to accept the truth from whomsoever and from wherever it may come (Ibn ben Sar- Sufi master)

In July 1977, a few months after I had recovered from a bout of typhoid, my cousin Romy and her husband Ben arrived to visit me in La Paz from South Africa en route to San Diego to see Ben’s sister. I believe that their visit was governed by affection, real curiosity to see and experience a new and strange place, and also to check out on behalf of the rest of the family how cousin Ken, who was now living in Bolivia (of all places), was doing.

Down the Andes  - The Road of Death

Romy and Ben had about a week to spend in Bolivia, and asked me what there was to do and see. I told them of the glories of Lake Titikaka, the Inca Island of the Sun, and the pre Inca ruins of Tiahawanaco, of the fiestas, the weavings, and the music of the highlands. All relatively safe options and easily accessible. They were politely interested but not enthusiastic.
Then Ben asked me whether it was possible to visit the Amazon rain forest, and was it accessible from La Paz? Actually yes, it is very accessible. Not the Amazon River itself, but one of its large tributaries which runs through the virgin rain forest of North Eastern Bolivia. A mere 80 kms from the high dry canyon in which La Paz lies, one is already in tropical mountain forest, and 60kms further on  one can take a trip through the rain forest by boat on the River Beni.
I tried to warn them that the rain forest is very hot and humid and boring when viewed from a river. One travels smoothly on the water enclosed by two green walls of impenetrable trees and vines. You almost never see animals because there is plenty of water in the small streams, so there is no need for animals to come down to the bank of the large river and expose themselves (unlike in drier savannah environments where the river is the only source of water). Also the rivers are wide so you don’t see much. And the Amazon basin does not have the large game of the African savannah. The largest animal is the Jaguar which is almost never spotted as it hunts mainly at 
night; the others are mainly wild pigs, small deer, tapirs and monkeys. There are no large antelope or large apes, and the crocodiles are small. There are plenty of birds of course, but they are best worth watching from the few open spaces of land. Not from the middle of a river.
But Ben was adamant. So we decided to take a trip to Rurrenebaque, a small town on the river Beni on the edge of the last foot hills of the Andes. We would have to take local land transport from La Paz over the east slope of the Andes to Puerto Linares. Then a day long trip from there by small boat on the Beni to Rurrenebaque, from where we could take a light plane back over the Andes to La Paz.

The trip turned out to be not at all boring. And we did see a lot. And we experienced the beautiful, the shocking and the unexpected, largely unplanned. And learned from it.

The first leg of our journey took us to Coroico, on the Eastern slopes of the Andes, a mere 85kms from La Paz. The road ascends east out of La Paz through interminable adobe houses. There is the usual roadblock at edge of the city where vendors sell bread, Pan derumbe they call it. Landslide bread! Meaning you will need bread while you wait who knows how long for the authorities to clear the road if there is a landslide. Landslides are very common on the steep soft sedimentary Andean slopes after rain when the soil above bedrock gets saturated and starts to slide. Fortunately there was no landslide that day. Only 20 kms from La Paz, the minibus reached the top of the pass (called the ‘cumbre’) at 4800m. We were almost at the snow line, in a bleak tundra like place beside a round glistening lake. Even in that cold (It was about 3 degrees centigrade,) there were llamas and alpacas grazing on the swamp grass by the lake shore.

From there it was all downhill. Today one travels down to Coroico by a safe two way paved road. But in 1977 there was only that one lane dirt road which in only 60 kms drops from 4800m to an altitude of only 1200 m. This road is now used mainly for tourists who cycle down it from the cumbre for the thrill in organized groups. But in 1977 it took all the traffic between La Paz and the lowlands.
It is one of the great scenic journeys of the world. Within a short distance of 60 kms, there is a 3600m drop in altitude. One can witness all the vegetation types, from small tuft tundra grass and lichens to tropical mountain forest , that one would see if one travelled from the Arctic tundra to the equator in regions of high rainfall!
At about 2300m one passes through a region of mist and ghostly trees festooned with orchids clinging to their branches as parasites. The route is so precipitous that most of the way the road is cut into almost sheer mountainside. The slope across which the road traverses is so steep, that at times water pours onto the edge from a rock overhang above. And the scale is awesome. Standing in one place one can look above at snow - capped mountains and below at tropical palm trees.
 The road has since been called the 'Road of Death' and cited as the most dangerous road in the world. Because it is so narrow ,it is extremely dangerous for four wheeled traffic, there are extra widened places cut into the rock. They are barely the length of a vehicle, but are the only places where two vehicles coming from opposite directions can pass each other. There have been frequent bus disasters on this road and its fork to Chulumani; which is still exclusively used, the most recent in January 2012. Here and there one sees little crosses on the side of the road to remind travellers that some vehicles don’t make it.
A couple of times when another vehicle came up the road towards us, we had to reverse into one of these bays. Then we all got out of the bus, and stood about shouting encouragement to the two brave drivers  who were engaging in a life threatening exercise of trying to squeeze past each other on the edge of a precipice.
Finally we arrived in Coroico, a few kms off the main road to Caranavi to where we were headed the next day. It is a delightful little subtropical town at 1700m perched on a saddle 500m above a wild rushing river. That night we slept in a pension in a room which smelled strongly of mildew. The next day we walked down the hill to the main road through coffee plantations. On the way we sampled the coffee berry. Few people know that the coffee bean is actually the pit of a small round brown berry like fruit and is surrounded by sweet pulp.
We waited about an hour on the road for transport. Then a three ton open truck stopped for us. It had come down the road from La Paz and was empty except for four small Ayamara men (indigenous Indians from the La Paz area), still wrapped up against the highland cold and wearing colourful knitted woolen caps on their heads. They stared silently at the three big ‘gringos’ with large backpacks who climbed in and carefully leaned their packs against the wall of the truck. 
We were still in tropical mountain country, and the dirt road, thankfully now two lanes, followed a quite substantial river. But the truck was moving extremely fast. Romy pleaded with me to tell the driver to go slower, but she didn’t understand the weak position we were in as passengers of an open truck. This was no luxury bus. It was the cheapest and crudest form of motor transport available. The prevailing ethos was that he was doing us a favour even if we were paying. I would have offended his macho sensibilities if I said anything to him about his driving. In fact he could have thrown us off the truck. So I said nothing.
The four little men were staring gravely at us, trying to get used to our strangeness. Then one got up and lurched over to me and addressed me in Ayamara. (the pre Inca language  still spoken in the region centred on Lake Titikaka) I replied in Spanish, but it was obvious he hardly understood me. Despite this, our encounter was all incoherent goodwill on both sides, with body language doing the job that the spoken word could not. Elated, he staggered across the truck to where the packs were standing, opened his fly and let loose. Then he swaggered back to his mates, proud of his enhanced status. He had overcome his shyness and had dared to speak with the big strangers. Romy spoke about disinfecting the packs, but the 100kmp hour wind at 30 degrees dried them in less than a minute.
We got to Caranavi late that afternoon. In those days it was a disorganized little frontier town on the edge of freshly cleared rain forest. When I visited it 30 years later in 2007 it had grown into a small modern city, with rush hour traffic and street lights. I am told that it is now the centre of the Bolivian cocaine trade. We were directed to a residencial, (cheap hotel), a cluster of modest buildings. While I negotiated accommodation with the owner, Ben went to inspect the communal pit toilets and when he returned he announced that they were filthy and we could not stay there. He proposed setting up his two- man tent in the town plaza, but I persuaded him not to. Thieves and corrupt police would ensure that we wouldn’t last the night camped out in the middle of town. So we settled for the residencial and slept on beds with linen under mosquito nets. For $1.50 each!
The next day we travelled again by truck to Puerto Linares, a straggle of wooden buildings on the bank of the 100m+ wide River Beni. It was midday when we got there, and I was told that we would be able to arrange a passage on one of the boats that were arriving from Rurrenebaque that evening. The boats carried produce back and forth on the river, and also took three or four passengers. That evening I secured a passage for us for the next day on a small barge like boat, more like a large flat bottomed canoe with an outboard motor. We slept badly that night in a room in the grandly named Residential Beni, kept awake until the early hours by somebody’s radio blaring irritating schmaltzy Latin American pop through the thin wooden walls.

On and in the Beni River

Motorised canoes  used for transport in the Amazon basin- Like that which capsized   

There was a warm mist over the river at dawn when we made our way to the boat. It was piled with sacks of sugar and maize meal, and we sat on top of them. The other passenger on our boat was a tiny elderly peasant woman with numerous bundles. She told me she was travelling to Rurrenebaque to stay with her son. The pilot manned the motor at the rear, while his assistant navigated by watching the river at the front.
They took the boat skilfully onto the river. The trees on the opposite bank showed as dark faint shapes. It was very silent and peaceful. The rising sun shone red through the mist, and the water shimmered like liquid gold. Ben and I took off our shoes and shirts and we lay on top of the sacks as the boat moved smoothly through paradise.
But this was not quite a drift through paradise. It was the short dry season, the river was lower than normal, and we weren’t yet out of the Andean foothills. From time to time the channel narrowed and we would enter slight rapids. When this happened, the pilot would turn down the motor and allow the boat to drift with the current. Then as it entered the middle of the rapid he would turn the engine on hard, and we would swing through on the deeper outside bend. This was necessary because the rapid almost always occurs in a bend of the river, and there was a danger of running aground on the shallow inner side of the loop.
On one rapid however, the tactic didn’t work. When he turned up the motor to shoot round the bend, the front of the boat swung towards the shallow bank at right angles to the current, and the boat grounded, stuck in the sand and stones. The pilot motioned for Ben and me to wade into the water to help them free it. Romy remained sitting on top of the sacks surrounded by clothes and passports and our packs. With water to our waists, we pushed and pulled and succeeded only to well. The boat came free and started to slide back into the water, engine end forward. But the weight of the engine pulled it down, and it started shipping water.
And then it sank.
My adrenalin must have kicked in then. I became a spectator of what seemed a dream or a movie. Suddenly there was no boat anymore, and we were all in the water like Alice in the pool of tears or Titanic passengers. I remember the assistant pilot splashing past me carrying the wailing old lady on his shoulders. I saw Ben wading or swimming downstream following his floating backpack. Mine had disappeared, but unaccountably my sleeping bag was floating next to me.
. And so was Romy who was crying that she was drowning.
‘Swim’, I shrieked. I knew she was a good swimmer.
‘My boots are pulling me down.’(She and Ben had bought matching leather boots for their South American trip).
‘Take them off!’
‘I can’t,’ she sobbed, ‘and they cost R50’ (about  $300 today's equivalent)
Then the assistant pilot having deposited the old lady on the shallow bank, was back, and grabbed Romy and pulled her across the river leaving her unaccountably on the steeper opposite bank. By now Ben had disappeared downstream around a bluffas had the pilot. I swam to the shallow bank with my sleeping bag. I had lost my back pack with my clothes, my shoes, money and Bolivian ID. I had nothing except the shorts I was wearing and a wet sleeping bag. The old lady was with me on my side of the river, weeping under a bush nearby. There was no sign of her bundles, her life possessions. Romy and Ben were on the opposite bank about 150 m apart and separated by a steep promontory. I could see both of them, but they were out of sight of each other. Ben was downstream while Romy was directly across from me. I could also see the pilot and his assistant downstream beyond the rapids where the river was calm and wide. They had found the boat and had beached it on a sand bar and were trying to rescue as many sodden white bags of sugar and maize out of the river as they could find.
It was now about midday. The sky was cloudless and it was very hot .And there we were, stranded on the banks of a river in the remote rain forest of the Bolivian Amazon. Like castaways, I reflected. But if so then where was the Lord of The Flies to stop the relentless sand midges from biting my bare feet?
Both Romy and Ben wanted to get into the water to swim over to my side. They were frantic because they thought the other had drowned. The river was just too wide for them to hear me yelling that I could see them both and that they were ok. Finally I got them to understand, and they decided to wait until they had got over the shock of the accident before attempting to swim back. Then the pilot and his assistant returned from downstream and told me that the boat engine was flooded and damaged and that although there was no hope of re-launching it , we were not to worry, as there were plenty of other boats coming down the river which would rescue us.
And sure enough about an hour later, I heard a motor. And in that unexpected almost surreal way I have come to expect from scenes in South America, there came chugging down the untamed river Beni, a small blue and white boat with a high shade canopy. Sitting in it was a fat balding middle aged man with a clipped black moustache dressed impeccably in white pants and shirt. And next to him was an equally fat middle aged woman in a pink and white dress with perfectly coiffured hair. It was as if they were taking a Sunday cruise on the Seine or around a lake in a park in Buenos Aires.
We yelled and gesticulated and he brought the boat over. The pilot explained to him what had happened, so he crossed the river and fetched Romy and Ben. It turned out that this man, Diego Rodriguez, was a sort of minor Onnasis of the river Beni. He was the owner not only of our boat, but several others. In those days boats were the only means of transport on the surface between the populated highlands and the flat largely uninhabited rain forest and pampa (tropical grassland) of La Paz department. (I wonder what happened to the river transport business when they built the road from Caranavi to Rurrenebaque in the early 1990s.)
But we still had to wait a while longer, because Rodriguez refused to take us in his boat. He obviously did not see himself as a heroic captain rescuing survivors. He just regarded us as a nuisance. He agreed to take the old lady, but told us that there was no room for us, however another of his boats was coming soon and it would take us to Rurrenebaque. I protested that we were traumatized by the accident and showed him my feet which were starting to swell from midge bites. But he disregarded my pleas. He said he would ‘fix us up in Rurrenebaque’ when we got there and chugged off down the river.
It was dawning on me that this man was responsible for us because we had capsized in his boat. I would have to make sure that he would compensate us adequately and get us back to La Paz. I had lost my back pack and all the money I had brought with me as well as my clothes. Romy had lost her passport. Ben had managed to keep his pack with his clothes and two- man tent, but had lost his watch, a family heirloom, and one of his boots. But what good is one boot to a two legged man? He carried it with him for a couple of days, forlornly hoping either to find the other boot somewhere down river, or a one legged man to give it to. Eventually he threw it away.
Ben also still had his traveller cheques which were in his money belt which had stayed around his waist. I determined then that I was going to make Rodriguez pay at the very least for the remainder of our trip, and also buy me clothes. So it was important that he shouldn’t know that we still had money. I suspected that he had to think we were destitute if we were to get any compensation out of him. The pilot advised me to report the matter to the ‘port captain’ or police chief in Rurrenebaque and to enlist his help in negotiating compensation.

Dynamite Gorge

 Bala Gorge, River Beni . This could well be the very spot where this drama took place

Not long after that, as the fat man had promised, another boat similar to ours came by and picked us up. We proceeded down river towing our incapacitated boat which now was reloaded with some of the rescued sodden sugar and maize flour bags! Were they going to still try to sell them soaked in river water? I wondered. It was by now late afternoon and we were still some hours from Rurrenebaque. As boats didn’t travel the river in the dark, we would have to find a place to camp that night. More midges, I thought, looking at my swollen feet. But the danger to us that night was not to be from midges.
The river was narrowing and we entered what appeared to be a fairly long gorge with steep walls. Suddenly the pilot swerved the boat and made for the left bank. Two men had appeared out of the bush and were hailing us. As we got nearer, I saw big tough fearsome looking individuals with bloodstained clothes and rifles slung over their shoulders. They carried two dead howler monkeys which they must have recently shot. They told us that they were professional hunters, and asked the pilot for a ride back to their camp a few kms downstream.
‘No!’ exclaimed Romy, 'These men cannot come on board. They are cruel. I disapprove of hunting poor defenceless animals!’
But of course they came on board. They after all had the guns. And it wasn’t our decision to make but the pilot’s .Like on the truck to Caranavi; I was becoming aware of our role in the unfolding drama of this trip. We were not decision makers but also we were not mere spectators as tourists usually are. We were guests or passengers. We were not determining events, or just watching them, they were being thrust on us, and their real significance lay in how we chose to react and what we learned from the experience. The way they were presenting themselves seemed to be to teach us the importance and sheer necessity of shedding preconceived ideals and conceptions in the face of the reality of basic survival. I thought how strange it is that tourists subconsciously crave ‘experience’ and ‘excitement’ in their paid for travels, but at the same time demand absolute safety from their guides and tour companies. A contradiction. Of course you can’t experience anything new or meaningful unless you engage, and that means taking the risk of losing. Otherwise you may as well stay home and look at photos or watch a travel movie.
So we continued downstream with the hunters on board, and a few kms further on the pilot beached the boats at their camp in the gorge. They had invited us all to spend the night there, and the pilot had accepted on our behalf. The hunter’s camp was one of the most beautiful places I have ever seen. They had established themselves on a pristine white sand beach wedged between verdant cliffs and the river. A small waterfall tumbled down from the cliff onto the beach and made a pool in which several large fish were swimming. Bags and bed rolls and cooking utensils were lying around, but I didn’t see any tents.
They lit a fire and the pilot told me that we were invited to eat dorado (golden) fish with them. They took them from the pool and were preparing to barbeque them on an open fire. Romy and Ben declined the invitation and seemingly oblivious of the insult to our hosts by  declining their  hospitality, or the irony of  what they were doing, went up the beach and opened a can of tuna which Ben had brought with him from South Africa !
I thought not only of our safety. I couldn’t allow them to ignore our hosts like this. I pleaded with them to join us .
How do we know whether the Beni River where the fish come from isn’t polluted?’ Argued  Romy.
I reminded her that she and Ben had already involuntarily swallowed large quantities of the river’s water only that morning, and were still alive. So well grilled fish from the river was unlikely to harm them. But I also tried to make them aware of the rules of hospitality in wild places. You don’t question it, and you have to accept it when it is they not you who control the situation.
I did finally persuade them to join the barbeque. And of course there was no contest taste wise between fresh river fish and tinned shredded tuna!
We sat into the mild night beneath brilliant stars while the hunters and boat pilots regaled us with their stories. I reflected that another lesson we were learning on this trip was to understand that there are some circumstances when you cannot control events and that survival depends on going with the flow. This can sometimes mean accepting help from unexpected quarters. And being destitute actually makes it easier to learn these lessons because you can’t buy your way out of the experience.
When we got up to go to sleep, the pilots and hunters unrolled their bed rolls on the sand. By now my sleeping bag had dried out and I was prepared to sleep next to them beneath the stars, but Ben and Romy insisted I join them in the two man tent to protect  ourselves against mosquitoes. So we three adults tried to fit into Ben’s two man tent. It was stifling hot. We shifted and rolled around trying to get comfortable.
Then just when I was dozing off, We were awakened by a deafening explosion. Something hit the tent and it collapsed. Three adults then tried to escape from the fallen tent. This was the stuff of slapstick comedy, but there was no one around to enjoy it. Somehow we did get out of the tent without ripping it, and Ben found his torch in his pack. Miraculously it was still working. There was no sign or sound of the others sleeping further down the beach. What on earth had happened?
The torch light revealed several pieces of dead fish on the ground. One piece had obviously hit the tent at great speed and knocked it over. There was no other explanation. But how on earth had half a fish flown through the air? And what was the explosion which preceded it? We were too tired to speculate that night, and didn’t link the two events to come up with the only possible explanation. So we pitched the tent again and slept fitfully in it until dawn. It had been a long and eventful day.
The next day we prepared to continue our journey to Rurrenebaque. The pilot told us that the hunters had already left in the night. They had provided food for themselves by throwing dynamite into the river, literally blowing fish out of the water. A crude and cruel way to fish and also wasteful, because spawn gets killed as well by the blast. But men in pristine wildernesses whernature’s abundance seems so limitless don’t consider the longer term ecological consequences of their actions. Until it’s almost too late.

Rurrenebaque

                              Rurrenebaque today much grown,showing parrot island.

So we set out that morning down the Beni for Rurrenebaque, and arrived a few hours later without further incident. The river widens where it leaves the last foothills of the Andes, and it starts to meander across the flat limitless Amazon basin, its channel divides, and the two channels form an island in the middle .On the right bank of the right hand channel lies Rurrenebaque. As we approached the town, I saw several boats were pulled up on the flat sand beach next to a large truck. This was the ‘harbour’. Our boat beached, we said our goodbyes and thanks to the pilots and their assistants, and approached Rodriguez who was supervising the loading of produce into the truck.  He told us to go to the hotel where we were to be accommodated at his expense, and that he would ‘see us later’. Round one to us without even trying!
The hotel was a rambling wooden building with a large verandah overlooking the river. It seemed to cater to tourists, because several careful middle aged people were sitting taking drinks or tea. They were extremely surprised to see us straggle in, Ben and I unshaven, me now at least wearing one of Ben’s T shirts, but still barefoot. Fortunately the owner, a kindly German lady, had been warned by Rodriguez to expect us, and made us immediately welcome with hot soup. The hotel building was full, so Ben and Romy were given a large tent with camp beds, linen etc, while I shared a dormitory room.
That afternoon Ben and I went to the ‘police’ station to report the accident to the port captain. The building was closed. We found his home and roused him from his siesta. He got dressed in his uniform and we proceeded to the station where he slowly and formally typed our report of the accident, and gave me a copy (which I still have).He didn’t seem surprised; obviously word had got around. Then he arranged a meeting for us with Rodriguez for the next morning and agreed to mediate.
We walked the few blocks back to the hotel. There I saw that Romy had put out several things to dry on the lawn in front of their tent. Among them, neatly laid out in full view of passers by, were Ben’s purple American Express traveller cheques. Money which we weren’t supposed to have.
I tried to convince her that our alleged total destitution was the only insurance we had of getting something out of Rodriguez at the meeting the next day. We certainly weren’t in a place where justice would automatically be done. If he knew that we had any money, he would wash his hands of us, and the port captain wouldn’t help either, because it turned out he was married to Rodriguez’s sister. So we were going to have an uphill battle at the negotiations. Finally I convinced her that it would be a far greater dishonesty if Rodriguez didn’t compensate us at least for some of what we had lost, than for us to lie about our true financial state which any way should not be a factor in the negotiation for compensation. So she agreed to put the cheques out of sight inside the tent, and thankfully word of their existence didn’t get to Rodriguez.
Our protracted negotiations the next morning were made more difficult by my broken Spanish, but were helped by Ben’s burly presence. Rodriguez’s first offer was a free lift back to Puerto Linares on one of his boats. This we flatly refused. La Senora esta traumatizada’ (the lady, meaning Romy, is in shock) I remember saying. What I really meant was that there is no way any of us would ever go on one of his boats again. And anyway what would we do in Puerto Linares without money? How would we get back to La Paz? Then I told him that we were tourists in his beautiful country and that the tourism authorities would not be at all pleased to hear how we were being treated. That clinched it. The port captain didn’t want any trouble from his superiors. So he had a hasty conference outside with his brother in law, and the upshot was that Rodriguez finally agreed to pay not only for our stay at the hotel, but also for our air tickets back to La Paz. He then took me to his shop, and I was allowed to pick out a flimsy pair of trousers, a shirt and a cheap pair of tennis shoes.
We spent the next two days recuperating in Rurrenebaque. One late afternoon Romy and I visited the island, while Ben stayed behind to clean his camera. There we witnessed the sudden arrival of hundreds of parrots which unaccountably fly to the island from the mainland every evening before sunset. They weigh down the trees and scream and chatter to each other for about half an hour. And then just as mysteriously they fly back to the forest after the sun goes down. While we were waiting for the boatman to fetch us, a brief shower sent us scurrying for shelter under large banana leaves.

Over the Andes


Rodriguez duly bought us our plane tickets to La Paz. Planes left in those days from Reyes, another town about 40 kms away. We went there by motor bike taxi, (The roads are usually too bad for four wheeled vehicles), and spent the night in a residencial, sleeping in hammocks. Then early the next morning we again took motor bike taxis to the air strip. Reyes airstrip serves a military base. We were not heartened by the sight of the twisted remains of several aircraft surrounding the runway, or by the appearance of our plane. It was grey and shaped like an egg with wings. It was actually an Israeli made military transport plane not designed to take commercial passengers.
We climbed in and sat on canvas ‘benches’ strung along the sides, facing our luggage which was piled in the middle. There were no seatbelts. One passenger was an injured little girl who was being taken to La Paz for x rays. The authorities insisted on consulting with Ben about her health, although he is a vet. I remember there were also two proud young pureblood Indian men in the plane, highlanders who stuck out incongruously amongst the slightly built lowland meztizos.
As was to be expected, we sat waiting an interminable time inside the plane before take off. The heat was stifling, so I was thankful when it did finally take off and the air cooled as we gained altitude. Of course that meant that the cabin wasn’t pressurized, but I didn’t realize that immediately. I did notice that some passengers were bending forward heads between their knees. Then someone next to me suddenly threw up over the baggage, but fortunately missed ours. And the injured girl had started crying. I looked through the open door to the pilot’s cabin and saw that he had an oxygen mask and was motioning to his co pilot to give it to the girl. Ben told me that he motioned to him to keep it. Our safety depended on him having the oxygen! But my mind was still working very slowly. I wasn’t putting together the implications of what I was seeing.
Then I looked out of the window. I saw snow capped mountains about two thousand feet below AND WE WERE FLYING OVER THEM! That meant we were well over 5000m. Without oxygen! It dawned on me that most of the people in the plane were suffering from altitude sickness. So then of course I immediately started to feel nauseous! And all through this, the two highlanders sat serenely, even contemptuously, watching us suffer. Altitude was no problem to them, whose ground level existence started at nearly 4000 metres. Fortunately my dizziness didn’t last long. And then we were descending in freezing drizzle to La Paz El Alto airport.

Postscript

When Ben and Romy left for the USA the next day, they told me that Ben's sister  had recommended that they visit Disneyland in Los Angeles. Romy later wrote to tell me that one ride they took there was a ‘jungle trip’ in a small boat conducted by a man dressed as a great white hunter in a pith helmet, while fearsome  (artificial) snapping crocodiles and hippos followed. I hope that their memory of this safe Disney fantasy experience has palled before the recollection of what happened to us in a real jungle (The word jungle comes from the Spanish jungla, which means impenetrable trees and vines. The correct term for all the environments is rain forest or selva in Spanish.)
















Sunday, May 13, 2012

John Mutonono . A Tale of Intervention,Redemption and Achievement

                                     John Mutonono






         A  True  Tale of  Intervention, Redemption and Achievement 
                   (and closure thanks to Facebook)
                                                by Kenneth Margo-kennethmargo@gmail.com


In early 1984 I saw a notice in the Guardian asking for teachers to apply to work under contract in Zimbabwe. I applied and was accepted and sent to Masvingo (formerly Fort Victoria), to teach at the previously whites only school, Victoria High.


Zimbabwe had received its independence in 1980, and the education system had been thrown open to all. High schools were offering the British Cambridge curriculum. By 2008 entire education system has collapsed. Teachers had disappeared, many having been killed and beaten for allegedly supporting the opposition MDC. But in the mid 1980s, five odd years into independence, the rampant cruelty and mismanagement and pillaging of the country hadn’t started. Mugabe was still treading carefully.
Victoria High School in Masvingo province was then a well equipped former white school with a boarding facility and extensive playing fields. I taught Geography Cambridge A level certificate there in 1987. The opportunity offered meant that even the children of poor rural families could gain admission to these former ‘whites only’ schools if their grades were good enough and they could afford the modest fees.

John Mutonono was one such poor student. John was tall, nearly two metres, and strong and gentle and respectful. He was an average student but had made it into his final A level year through hard work. It was January, the beginning of his last school year.
Then one day John wasn’t in class, and the next day he wasn’t there either. We teachers were told in a staff meeting that John had gone rather spectacularly off the rails, and was in the hospital, pumped full of drugs to keep him quiet. The story was bizarre. One day the usually gentle and quiet John had started bothering female students, by proposing marriage to them. Then he had marched to Mr Dube the headmaster’s office, barged in, and demanded the keys of his car, saying that he needed it to see some officials in Harare. The headmaster had agreed, and told John to wait outside, while he wound up a few things. Then he phoned the police, who came quickly, and took John away to hospital.
I was concerned about him, I knew that the hospital was drugging him, but couldn’t hold him indefinitely. And I was also concerned that if this ‘illness’ would last too long, his prolonged absence would jeopardize his chance of passing his A levels at the end of the year.
I knew nothing of his family, but kept up with the news of his condition from the school secretary. But I was also puzzled at the attitude of some of the other teachers. The Zimbabwean teachers didn’t seem to be overly concerned about John. Did they know something I didn’t? Was there something ‘cultural’ that I was missing?
In a subsequent staff meeting we were told that he had been discharged from hospital and was now at home with his mother about 100 kms away , deep in the rural ‘tribal trust’ areas. I proposed that some of us teachers go to visit him to find out how he was progressing. Two other expatriate teachers volunteered to go with me. But none of the Zimbabwean teachers did. Very strange, I thought, he is after all one of their own.
We drove along  dirt roads through interminable bush, and eventually found the collection of modest round huts and one rectangular building with a zinc roof that was John’s family compound. It was almost dark. His mother, an almost wizened woman in a doek (headscarf) welcomed us into the one roomed zinc roofed building and we told her our business. She listened sadly and then told us that John was not better, in fact he was very wild and she couldn’t handle him.
Then John burst into the room. He was manic, jumping up and down, hugging me and my two fellow teachers. He announced that he was going to kill a goat in my honour and rushed off into the night. I asked his mother if he had other male relatives to help her restrain him. She said that his father was dead. And then from her perspective the story came out.
His paternal grandfather who lived with them was jealous of John .He thought John was getting above his station (‘putting up his shoulders’ was the literal term) by getting an education and going to a ‘white ‘school. So he had spoken to the ancestors who were now possessing John and teaching him a lesson.
I was appalled. This was way beyond anything I could handle. But I was also angry. Was this going to be the reason why John, a poor boy of peasant upbringing, was going to lose all the prospects he had worked so hard for?
I realized intuitively that to cure John we would need to balance the situation ancestrally.
‘Do you have any male relatives?’ I asked her.
‘My brother works in Hwange’ she replied indifferently.
I asked her for his contact which she gave me reluctantly. That night I called John’s maternal uncle and explained the situation. He promised to act. And he did.
Three weeks later he phoned me and told me that John was with him and getting better. Three weeks after that he brought his nephew back to school. A very quiet almost emaciated John Mutonono. How his uncle had cured him I then had no idea, and he didn’t volunteer anything.
John greeted me gravely. He had lost much of his intensity and some of his intelligence. But not so much to stop him, after some intensive coaching from me and other  teachers, from writing his A Levels six months later in November and scraping a pass.
He came to see me the following term to thank me. I reckoned that he was well enough to be told about what we had all experienced during his illness. He confessed that he remembered absolutely nothing of that three month period, except he had been told that his uncle had taken him to a famous sangoma (spiritual and herbal healer) in Bulawayo where he had stayed a few days. He didn’t remember what had happened at the sangoma’s house.
Then I ventured to ask him something which had been puzzling me. ‘Why didn’t any of the Zimbabwean teachers get involved?’ I asked.
John shrugged. ‘They suspected’, he said,
‘Suspected what?’ But I understood now.
‘About my ancestors Mr. Margo, and they were afraid.

Postscript

Twenty five years later  in May 2012 I found  John on Facebook. I started corresponding with him ,and he sent me his CV . John has done well for himself. He has a MSc in Finance and BCom honours , and is today the  manager of a large  bank in Zimbabwe, is married with  six children and owns a prosperous stock farm in the Midlands . This is the email reply he sent to me on reading the story  I wrote about this incident  and which I sent him  on 11 May  2012

John Mutonono Johnmu@kingdom.co.zw
2:00 PM (42 minutes ago)

to me
Thank you very much for the story, I will keep it for my children to read. Thank you very much Mr Margo Only God knows why and how I managed to meet you. I will never forget your assistance to me, and the help you gave me when I was starting temporary teaching. I pray that one day we will be able to meet again. Please let me have the other stories if you are free to do so. Zimbabwe is still struggling economically because of sanctions and dollarization. Not much is being produced by our own local companies. Unemployment levels still soaring and liquidity challenges as people lack confidence in our local banks. A lot of things have changed some for the better others for worse.

My uncle my mother brother  who was in Hwange you talked to is now late. We also lost the last born sister she died  at the age of 21 on 11February 2009 in a way which shocked all of  us  she was not suffering from anything.  The other three brothers and four remaining sisters are all qualified teachers and they now all have their families. My mother is still alive though growing old.

All those other relatives who were trying all sorts of funny things on me and our family  are now late  together with their wives. God punished them, one of them hanged himself inside a hut.

Thank you.
Will want to continue keep in touch with you.
Regards
John



From: Kenneth Margo [mailto:kennethmargo@gmail.com]